The Sunni-Shia divide is one of the most significant theological splits in Islam. While most Muslims advocate unity, some Sunni scholars consider certain Shia beliefs as Kufr (disbelief). This blog explores why some Sunni scholars hold this view, backed by Quranic verses, Hadith, and historical context.
⚠️ Note: This is a sensitive topic—we aim for objective analysis, not provocation.
1. Key Reasons Why Some Sunni Scholars Label Shia as Kafir
🔹 1. Rejection of Sahaba (Companions of the Prophet ﷺ)
Many Shia scholars curse and reject major Sahaba, including:
- Abu Bakr (RA)
- Umar (RA)
- Uthman (RA)
📜 Sunni View:
The Quran praises the Sahaba:
“Allah is pleased with them, and they are pleased with Him.” (Quran 98:8)
Rejecting them is seen as rejecting Quranic praise, which some consider Kufr.
🔹 2. Belief in Tahreef (Alteration of the Quran)
Some Shia scholars (like Al-Kulayni) claim the Quran is incomplete or altered.
📜 Sunni View:
Allah promises Quran’s protection:
“Indeed, it is We who sent down the Quran, and indeed, We will be its guardian.” (Quran 15:9)
Claiming the Quran is changed is directly against Allah’s promise, leading some to label it as Kufr.
🔹 3. Belief in Imamate & Infallibility of Imams
Shia believe in 12 Infallible Imams, considering them higher than Prophets (except Muhammad ﷺ).
📜 Sunni View:
- Only Prophets are infallible (Ma’sum).
- The concept of divinely appointed Imams is not in Quran or Hadith.
Some Sunni scholars argue this belief contradicts Islamic monotheism (Tawheed).
🔹 4. Cursing Aisha (RA) & Other Wives of the Prophet ﷺ
Some extremist Shia groups insult Aisha (RA), accusing her of betrayal.
📜 Sunni View:
The Quran defends Aisha (RA):
“Allah has declared the innocence of your wife.” (Quran 24:11)
Cursing the Mother of the Believers is seen as insulting the Prophet ﷺ, which some consider Kufr.
2. What Do Classical Sunni Scholars Say?
📌 Ibn Taymiyyah’s View:
“Those who curse the Sahaba are either Kafir or Fasīq (sinful).” (Minhaj al-Sunnah)
📌 Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal’s View:
“Whoever reviles the Companions is not a Muslim.” (Usul al-Sunnah)
📌 Modern Scholars’ Stance:
- Most mainstream Sunni scholars avoid Takfir (excommunication) on all Shia.
- Only extremist groups (like Wahhabis) declare all Shia as Kafir.
3. Do All Sunni Scholars Agree?
❌ No! Many Sunni scholars (like Yusuf al-Qaradawi) reject blanket Takfir:
“Not all Shia are Kafir; only those who reject clear Quranic verses.”
✅ Key Takeaway:
- Extremist Shia beliefs (like Quran alteration) are labeled Kufr.
- Moderate Shia (who respect Sahaba) are not automatically Kafir.
4. How Should Muslims Approach This Issue?
⚖️ Islamic Ruling:
- Avoid unnecessary Takfir.
- Focus on unity against common enemies.
- Debate with knowledge, not emotions.
📖 Quranic Advice:
“And do not argue with the People of the Scripture except in the best manner.” (Quran 29:46)
Conclusion
While some Sunni scholars label certain Shia beliefs as Kufr, mainstream Islam avoids blanket Takfir. The key issue lies in rejecting Sahaba, Quran alteration, and extremist views. Muslims should focus on unity, avoid sectarian violence, and debate with wisdom.
📢 Was this helpful? Share with others to promote informed discussions!